May 24, 2010 – Federalist No. 19 – Cathy Gillespie
Monday, May 24th, 2010
Professor Knipprath, thank you for an essay that goes way beyond Federalist 19, addressing the natural order of the universe! Your observations not only reflect what we have seen in history, but also what we are seeing in our country today.
Federalist 19 continues to reveal to us that the United States system of government as outlined in the Constitution is not just the result of our founding fathers’ vivid imaginations and creativity. The system of government they designed is based on an astute observation of history, an analysis of strengths and weaknesses of the governmental systems of many civilizations, and the improvements upon those systems our founders devised, taking into account their deep understanding of human nature, the people of the United States, and the resources of our great land.
Publius’ arguments for ratification are compelling because he doesn’t simply give an opinion, he backs up his position with example after example.
One of the last sentences of Federalist 19 caught my eye:
“So far as the peculiarity of their case will admit of comparison with that of the United States, it serves to confirm the principle intended to be established. Whatever efficacy the union may have had in ordinary cases, it appears that the moment a cause of difference sprang up, capable of trying its strength, it failed.”
Unlike many governmental systems in history, the system of government designed by our founders, within the structure of our Constitution, has allowed our country to withstand differences capable of “trying our strength.” Our system of government has not failed us, even in trying times. We survived the Civil War. We survived the Great Depression. We survived riots in the 1960’s. We survived World War I, World War II and terrorist attacks upon our country. We will survive the current immigration problems besieging many of our states. Through the course of history we have calibrated and recalibrated the course of our Nation through our elected representatives.
I believe that is what Andy was trying to say in a post this weekend:
“This country was founded on the ability to change direction in government by the vote. That happened two years ago because a majority of people felt change should happen. If that change went too far, then an opportunity to reset the course will occur in November.”
and what Janine says in her FoxNews Op-ed, Your Vote is Your Voice: http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2010/04/30/janine-turner-supreme-court-justice-constitution-elections-elected/
Going back to Professor Knipprath’s essay, an informed, educated and engaged citizenry is the energy that keeps our Republic from decay. It is what keeps our system of government so carefully constructed by our founders, from failing us during the trying times.
The responsibility rests with We The People. When we understand our rights embodied in the United States Constitution as well as the principles upon which this country was founded, we can elect those who will use the Constitution as our guiding light as we forge the course of the future, keeping us strong during the times capable of “trying our strength.”
Good night and God Bless!